Mathematics is a plural because many ways to “represent ideas to allow reasoning about them” have been devised. That little “s” also implies that more can be invented as needed.
- Alan Kay
Notes
- There's no news about new - Alan Kay
- @madeofmistak3 It's also a misaphorism. Blood is thicker than water means the opposite of what people think it does
- I'm accepting nominations: who's the Bertrand Russel of today? Math friends, please help!
- Turns out Jason Brennan made exactly this point but better 6 years ago https://nearthespeedoflight.com/article/2013_03_24_the_programming_environment_is_the_programming_language_
- If you're curious about "formal methods" (like TLA+ or Alloy), but don't know if they're too *formal* for you, Hillel Wayne (@hillelogram) makes The Case for Formal Methods on today's episode of the Future of Coding podcast: https://futureofcoding.org/episodes/038
- Thanks to our sponsor @replit for the transcript https://futureofcoding.org/episodes/038#full-transcript
- RT @pchiusano: This thread. There can be a high cost to having to convince the computer of termination (which is kind of a weak property an…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- @qualmist I would argue that order trees only *seem easier* to implement on a computer because our FP notation prioritizes lists over sets. My real gripe here is that parent/children is complicated enough to work with without having to also worry about older/younger sibling
- RT @shapr: Is "techo chamber" already a thing? That is, only talking to people who resemble your technical opinions?
Reposted by Steve
- I am now a patron of the very funny @madeofmistak3, and you should be too if you want to help make programmers laugh: https://patreon.com/madeofmistake?utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter&utm_campaign=tyshare2
- @pchiusano https://x.com/stevekrouse/status/1116063244463087617/photo/1
- RT @pchiusano: Haskell: *confusing type error* Me: Hmm what about... THIS instead Haskell: *even more confusing type error* Me: ... *stares…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- Last night someone made an analogy to explain their field (finance) in terms of my field (engineering), and it didn't make any (engineering) sense. I'm normally the one committing this thought-crime, so it was interesting to be on the other side of it /cc @hillelogram
- "Most people will probably get as much benefit out of exercise and getting adequate sleep than about using any sort of tool no matter what it is in programming." - @hillelogram
- If you are a typeclass/category theory person, I put quotes around "summing" above to indicate that I mean mappend, a more abstract/generalized kind of combining two things
- One of the most powerful analytical tools: converting many seemingly-incompatible ideas into a common form for "summing" them up
- The simplest example of this is the weighted average. Another example is a pros/cons list
- The key insight is that every factor you are considering in a single decision must (by virtue that you are considering it) be *somehow* convertible to a common form with all the other things in consideration. Even if *how* you can convert it isn't immediately apparent
- @MaineFrameworks https://x.com/stevekrouse/status/1115954142202290176/photo/1
- Twitter's char limit gives plausible deniability to roll the dice by being less than 💯 explicit about what we mean and see if anyone gets it -- or gets *really* offended by it. We can always follow up with "sorry, that's not what I meant. let me explain in more words..."
- @MaineFrameworks Good point! I think what really gets things confused is that we have all sorts of hacks to map HTML text's one-dimension of spatial ordering to the screen's two
- HTML is masquerading as a boring old tree when it's in fact a much more complicated species of "ordered tree" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tree_(data_structure)#Ordered_tree
- @Westoncb Hmm... where do you suppose the 'abstract concept of a painting' lives if not in the brain? What else is there of 'concept of painting' than that which is a 'mental experience'? I assume you're not thinking of Platoland, yes?
- Big surprise: the IRS doesn't tax-advantage open source. From my accountant: 'We don’t believe that the expenses related to writing open source software are deductible against your income, since there was no intent to make profit off the work."
- @Westoncb @DavidDeutschOxf And Gödel can't trap us here because we human analogies are too messy. We have no problems with partial understandings/correspondences. In fact that's all we have. The 'painting' in your brain is shallow, partial, and partially incorrect (and always will be)
- @Westoncb Maybe @DavidDeutschOxf's insight may be helpful here too: that there may be unthinkable thoughts is tantamount to a belief in magic. All things in reality will eventually yield to human comprehension. But we will never reach the end (always beginning of infinity)
- @Westoncb That was Papert from "Gears...". Hofstadter's "Analogy as the Core..." makes the similar case that humans understand by analogizing to what they have in their heads already. In that light, your question can't be answer in the abstract: depends on the human's previous knowledge
- @Westoncb Papert/Piaget may answer it: The understanding of learning must be genetic. What an individual can learn [..] depends on what models he has available. This raises, recursively, the question of how he learned these models... Intellectual structures grow out of one another
- @Stiivi 100% true. I'm just saying that our focus should be more on the environment than the language, while now it seems to be the other way around
- Our language and priorities are in need of an update: the programming environment is primary, PL is secondary https://x.com/girba/status/1115567492053766144
- Just learned that S. E. M. is another way to refer to the same idea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somebody_else%27s_problem /ht @Westoncb
- @seanmcdirmid18 I know! That's why it's so damn funny: the seemingly-accidental wordplay-metaphor of "typing strongly" is actually not wrong at all
- @Westoncb In other words I suspect we can triangulate the (infinite space/time) potential of the human brain between Godel, Church & Turing: no biologists required
- @Westoncb I don't 100% get this... but it makes me think of Gödel, and I wonder to what extent his insights apply here...
Text may be partial · Read original
- @Westoncb One issue I see with this metaphor is that the *key difference* between the sense of smell and the "sense" of cognition is one is "dumb sensor" (like you'r retina or tongue) and the other has a "Turing-complete CPU on board"
- We've got PL for programming language, and PX for programming experience. I propose PE for programming environment, on the grounds that it matters more for PX than PL does.
- (I was pre-primed by already knowing and loving his *Elephant In the Brain*)
- I don't think I've ever had such a strong "I want this person to be my friend" reaction than I just did to @robinhanson's bio http://www.overcomingbias.com/bio
- @flippacpub You're telling me! I just woke up after two hours of sleep for the same reason. Good luck to ya - you have all my empathies