What I would like to know:
1. Has any such environment been created or is still in existence?
2. What am I missing in this analysis?
🙏
Notes
- The experiments that approximate this in humans usually leave much to be desired. For example, there aren't enough twins separated at birth to take twin study results terribly seriously
- On the other hand, any experiment that claims to prove the ineffectiveness of education (nurture) and the supremacy of IQ (nature), simply has found 1 environment that doesn't allow humans to flourish arbitrarily much. This isn't hard. There are a million ways to limit humans
- The remaining, humane scientific tool at our disposal to settle the matter is to strive to create an environment that allows for the extreme flourishing of a random assortment of people such that it is throughly convincing. What a fun project!
- With other organisms, we succeed at teasing apart nature from nurture by simply holding genes constant and manipulating the environment. Of course, this would be inhumane with humans
- Yes, it is the classis nature vs nurture debate. This is why the debate has persisted for so long: it's difficult to tease out the effects of the genes from that of the environment.
- Side note: evolution works by fitting gene pools to environments, so this probably shouldn't be terribly surprising. End side note.
- The trouble with this particular belief is that it is hard to confirm or deny one way or another: if a specific human becomes extremely good at something, maybe it was in their genes. If a specific human fails to become good at something, maybe it was the environment
- I am convinced (but fully willing to be proved wrong) that in the right environment any human can be arbitrarily capable at whatever they wish to be
- Please please please I beg of you don't immediately discount me as an idealist that simply believes what I wish to be true. Yes I *want* this to be true. But I would prefer to know the *truth* if this is unfortunately false
- @underscorefunk Totally! It's a lot harder than it seems. I spent years on it and didn't make much progress. Lots of notes on my website. Happy to tell you more if you'd like
- It's telling that my top picks are both imaginary. It's probably because: 1. I haven't read enough biographies 2. The scientific mindset may be hard to judge from afar 3. Science is easier said than done
- My top pick is @ESYudkowsky's Harry Potter in Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality. My close second is Sherlock Holmes
- Which person, real or imaginary, best embodies the spirit of science 👩🔬?
- @runarorama This is the modern "it's impossible to have a good idea in the beltway"
- RT @tomaspetricek: "Why isn't there something as easy to use as spreadsheets, but as powerful as programming?" @jonathoda presenting to the…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- @underscorefunk Thanks for joining! So fun!
- RT @pel_daniel: @gabe_ragland @stevekrouse @ellenchisa @paulbiggar The response paper "Out of the tar pit" to Brooks' accidental complexity…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- @ShriramKMurthi I think you're in luck: that seems mostly false
- Request for startup: Patreon but you can also donate other forms of acknowledgement than money
- What is something you are unwilling to be wrong about? (Even if you are actually in fact wrong.) In other words, where are you most likely to be missing counter evidence?
- @hellonearthis @mpjme Wow! That's a lot to live up to
- @Ishendyweb @mpjme Few people seem to like this post but it's my best effort at explaining FRP concepts so far https://futureofcoding.org/essays/dctp.html
- RT @mpjme: On Monday morning, future of programming wizard @stevekrouse is guesting the live stream. We'll be geeking out on functional rea…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- @DavidDeutschOxf @sapinker @jasoncrawford @rootsofprogress @SamHarrisOrg & @EricRWeinstein: I think this is up your alley as well
- @DavidDeutschOxf & @sapinker: I think you'll both be very excited to learn about @jasoncrawford's new @rootsofprogress project! https://rootsofprogress.org
- RT @achrafkassioui: “Any sufficiently advanced user-facing program contains an ad hoc, informally-specified, bug-ridden, slow implementatio…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- RT @gabe_ragland: Highly recommend this Future of Coding episode where @stevekrouse talks with @ellenchisa and @paulbiggar about Dark (new…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- RT @geoffreylitt: This piece by @pchiusano is one of the best articulations I've seen of why software should move beyond "apps", and what t…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- I'm creating a list of @worrydream-inspired companies, such as @webflow, @NotionHQ, etc. Can you RT / reply to this with other such successful startups?
- RT @jasoncrawford: I haven't had a chance to blog about it yet, but a book I enjoyed was *The Box*, a history of containerization in the sh…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- @moiz_sakha @ShriramKMurthi @norbalm @Jew_Pakistani @iamShaniera @sayedzbukhari Amazing! Thank you! Despite the evidence of safety I was able to amass, my parents still have a strong negative emotional reaction to me going. If anyone has other ideas to help me put their minds to rest, I would be very greatful
- @tejasmanohar @bentossell Ditto!
- Is it safe for me in Karachi, Pakistan? I want to attend a friend's wedding. There will be security at all times but my parents still think it's crazy for me as a Jewish American given the US travel warning. Advice?
- A lil poem bout disagreement & learnin We disagree. So let's take a walk in each other's brains, you and me. See what I see and why I do, and I'll do the same for you. And if you see something in me that just isn't quite right, would you ever so kindly let me know?
- I found someone's wallet. There's a @monzo card inside. Any advice on getting in touch with her to give it all back?
- @disconcision Sounds like someone should learn more about the history and philosophy of science! Suspicions, beliefs, and vague intuitions are the meat of science! Could I get a hand here @tomaspetricek and @amb26ponder?
- RT @jasoncrawford: Someone asked me recently what's a boring topic that I'm excited/fascinated by. That's easy: cement. If it's wasn't th…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original
- @opeispo @DavidDeutschOxf defends the multiverse view well IMO
- RT @geoffreylitt: Sometimes debating best practices for "programming" feels ridiculously broad, like debating "writing". Writing an email,…
Reposted by Steve
Text may be partial · Read original