@Ceasar_Bautista Maybe you were weighing the chances of a particular startup higher than the base rate?
Notes
- @Nadagast Here's where I'll push back: why ever write a function with arguments? Why not just have everything operate on globally shared state? The reason for "exactly the relevant parameters and not any more" is the same with persistent state. We just don't have the tools to do it yet
- @Nadagast These questions are amazing! Short answer: 100% agree within existing tools. They don't have the power to do what I'm advocating so shoving all state in one db is the best answer we have
- @geoffreylitt My bias is firmly in favor of simple and precise abstractions a la FP, Conal Elliott, etc, so I'm just not excited about a solution that works outside that school of thought. You're right, probably should read it regardless though
- @geoffreylitt Ha yeah I think I met one of the guys who worked on the paper once. It's possible I'm missing some great insights because they're dressed up in language that's less accessible to me
- @Nadagast Well said! We think your data should live across exactly the components that it's relevant to. Not less or more. As opposed to a traditional db which is basically the mother of global mutable state all colocated, regardless of relevance between any parts
- One example of how confusing it is: Apple combines telephone calls and facetime calls in the same app. Ditto for texts and iMessages. I would've designed it that way myself but it confuses the hell out of mom
- Cell service is from antenna miles away Wifi is from a router only hundreds of feet away. Internet gets to your house via a wire (like electric power or telephone lines) and is turned into a wifi signal via routers
- Explaining wifi & cell service to one's parents: Telephone call =/ voice call SMS =/ text Cell service = Internet + telephone + SMS Wifi = Internet* Internet = everything - (telephone + SMS) *now with wifi calling, SMS (not iMessage) is the only thing wifi is missing
- @geoffreylitt Obviously love the goal/vision, but have very strong negative reactions how it proposes to achieve them. I'm just not going to like any FoC project that was using AngularJS in 2019. Just like I'm not going to like any project that's very OOP or has manual memory management
- I nominate @jack to be Batman https://x.com/JustJake/status/1429941223645597699
- Another way to think about it is what I said above: react (frp) extended in space (multiplayer) and time (persistence) so you can build components out of vertical slices of the stack
- Imagine: a react component that "carries around a database" inside itself. You can use it without thinking about threading persistent state down to the server and db. It just handles shuffling around events between users and persisting state within component
- That's not exactly how it'll work but hopefully it gives a provactive and enticing feel for what we're going for!
- Almost every part of the web stack is simple. Complication arises where they don't compose well to produce a unified set of building blocks for webby concepts: components, events, persistance, etc.
- Part of the magic of React is the component: a unifying abstraction across html, css and js. However react components don't cut across enough of the stack: they need to slice across "the server" and "the database" as well
- This is what we're doing at Compose: "abstraction[s] to create a new semantic level in which one can be absolutely precise" (Dijkstra) about webby concepts
- cc @tchncllytru
- "DNA has only 4 letters, but managed to generate you." - @gordonbrander It's managing on 3 letters!
- @jasoncrawford Important caveat: according to @Pinket's Better Angels, the 20th century wasn't actually more violent or deadly -- it was less -- it was just more traumatically, perceptually violent
- @brettberson I was trying to explain to non-tech folk how some employees in tech (engineers, PMs, founders) are treated as "the Talent" a la athletes, musicians. A (perceived) order of magnitude more focus on retention and employee happiness than other industries epitomized by Googleish perks
- Am I the only android user to have ever been tempted to manually type: Liked "their message" 🤦♂️
- @FISSIONcodes @geoffreylitt @SolidMit I agree. I personally am more biased towards greenfield architectures over building on top of existing ones. Which is why I admire (and envy) those like @geoffreylitt that have the patience to work more incrementally from where people are now to where he wants them to go
- @FISSIONcodes @geoffreylitt @SolidMit Exactly - same vision but approaching from the opposite angles: allowing developers to build new apps that can interop vs a layer atop existing apps that adds interop. I am not taking a position on which is "better", just making the distinction
- @FISSIONcodes @geoffreylitt @SolidMit That doesn't sound like it's as tailored to @geoffreylitt's "burning question" about companies mixing and matching data between existing apps. Am I missing something?
- "You know critical theory? It's basically the opposite of that" "Oh that make sense" "Studying and celebrating progress with a view how to achieve more of it" "How does this not already exist?" "I know right?!"
- It's one of my favorite dinner party facts that this field of study actually exists https://x.com/jasoncrawford/status/1429822472937893888
- @geoffreylitt @FISSIONcodes @SolidMit Love that first problem and the unifying vision as well. Just let us know the wiring details 😜
- @geoffreylitt This feels very similar to the @croquetio vision of a deeply collaborative operating system. However they're doing it from the AR/VR perspective, not the local first or data ownership perspectives
- And also let all your friends invest 🙋
- I'm pretty sure the rule is that now you have to make this https://x.com/geoffreylitt/status/1374144547555512322
- @KateandPie @BartoszMilewski Ha i was thinking the opposite. I'd like to read your whole book in tweets
- @jonathoda @geoffreylitt @rsms @_adamwiggins_ @andy_matuschak @craftdocsapp @mmcgrana Exciting!
- @jonathoda @geoffreylitt @rsms @_adamwiggins_ @andy_matuschak @craftdocsapp @mmcgrana Interesting! What alternatives are you considering?
- @jonathoda @geoffreylitt @rsms @_adamwiggins_ @andy_matuschak @craftdocsapp @mmcgrana What are your current answers to these three questions @jonathoda?
- @igblan Doesn't my Olympian analogy hold?
- "whole programming" (like "whole foods") https://x.com/spiralganglion/status/1428951614874738691
- 5/ So maybe one human has slightly faster or slightly more neurons than another. But the main difference is in the learning. And anything that anyone has learned, anyone else can learn.
- 6/ So if you want to be impressed by von Neumann, be impressed the way you would by an Olympic athlete. It's so much practice and preparation that it might look like magic
- 1/ This story has the feel of a religious miracle. It promulgates the view of inaccessible, inexplicable genius. There is no such thing https://x.com/fermatslibrary/status/1429061399007961099